Reviewing Bad Movie Reviews: Pixels


Share with friends

 

image-92

With a bevy of horrible summer movies stoking the ire of amateur critics everywhere, we thought we'd introduce a new category: Reviews of Bad Reviews

Title Card: August 2015

INT. FANCY HOLLYWOOD MOVIE THEATER. DAY

People of all creeds, colors, and orientations are gathered to watch the latest Tom Cruise four-wall action film. It’s before the previews and trailers start. Couples coo. Families converse. Loner dudes stare at their phones. A CINEMA EMPLOYEE walks to the front of the theater.

CINEMA EMPLOYEE

Hi everyone, I’m John, but my friends call me TotalHack97. I’ll be your cinema employee today and it’s my job to make sure you all have a pleasant theater-going experience. It’s not like we’re watching Pixels, right?

Silence. A long beat. A single cough breaks the silence.

CINEMA EMPLOYEE (cont’d)

Ok. Well, I’ll be checking in periodically to make sure the sound and picture quality are up to our theater chain’s stringent standards. Not like Pixels, though, that really is’t up to anyone’s standards, am I right? Pixels was a total nightmare, huh?

More silence.

CINEMA EMPLOYEE (cont’d)

Ok, everyone enjoy the show.

Fade to black.

This actually happened. We get it TotalHack97, Pixels wasn’t The Godfather, but it wasn’t the killing fields of Srebrenica, either. TotalHack97’s all-thumbs approach reminded me that there’s an unhealthy stench of hyperbole culture that has wafted too far into the day-to-day.

Sure, everyone’s a comedian and everyone’s a critic. And sure, criticism is a healthy activity that permits dialogue and engages your average human’s faculties. But the shrill, off-key caterwauling that drives page-views and elicits clicks should hardly be called criticism and actually runs counter to its purpose.

Take for example, the much shared (and recently lauded by the New Yorker) man-baby rantings of Pixel hater, Robert “MovieBob Chipman"... 

That over-caffeinated voice. The vitriol. The million-plus of views. You’d think that Adam Sandler killed his mom in cold blood with a crescent wrench. You’d think that writers Tim Herlihy and Timothy Dowling vivisectioned his childhood pet and BBQ’d it. His vitriol is so over-the-top, you wonder if he himself had been asked to write the movie, and then, just as he was handed the check, told, “Psych! JK, fatty!” He even employs strings of inartful profanity. Yes: INARTFUL. PROFANITY. Lines like “a waterfall of elephant jizz” make me cringe. His fans, in desperate acts of imitation, have said things like, “Adam Sandler is committing cultural genocide” which make me cringe even harder.

Ok, sure, it’s hardly the uninformed “gee-shucks” shill-work of say, Lawrence Toppman from the Charlotte Observer who might as well be fellating Sandler on the Time’s Square jumbotron with lauditory lines like, “The most remarkable technological achievement comes when the aliens use TV footage of 1980s icons to address our planet.” Toppman couldn’t have survived having his mind blown into tiny pieces by the technological wizardry of 1961s The Parent Trap, so he must be a recently thawed cave man. It’s the only explanation for that level of awe.

But, MovieBob’s caterwauling is a far cry from real professionals. People like Village Voice critic Amy Nicholson, who took time to explore (and entertainingly so) Sandler’s psychological issues as they are reflected in broader cinematic trends. She concludes, “Still, Sandler is following his own rules: Every year, he's gotta star in an expensive, anti-intellectual gasbag that anoints him the Best Boy in the World. And audiences are running out of quarters. “

Even Gawker, the veritable front of journalistic bad taste and poor editorial decisions, allowed Sam Biddle to paint a broader picture of Pixels as an example of Sony’s internal matrix of poor decision-making. “You could look at the disconnect between these internal emails and external reception and come to the shopworn-but-incontrovertible conclusion that, in Hollywood, No One Knows Anything. You can also feel a pang of sympathy for these poor, overpaid saps who watched each other pour tens of millions of dollars down the drain while keeping their game faces on and texting “Yes!” to the right people,” he writes.

What someone like MovieBob fails to realize is that each amateur-ish hyperbolic shellacking of a cultural product is a challenge of one-upmanship and and invites the world of self-obsessed trolls with similarly sensational affectations and anti-social superiority complexes into the conversation. It allows hyperbole to become the arbiter of taste. It forces the marshalling of armies and the drawing of arbitrary battle-lines over every little damn thing. It creates a world without nuance.

Maybe it’s the fact that MovieBob spent the past few years in the trenches of GamerGate (and, it would seem, sincerely on the reasonable side of it) and has already been called every awful thing imaginable by bigger and lowlier man-babies? Maybe that’s where all of the energy in his hatred comes from? Sure, anyone that survived that might be expected to have some small chip on his shoulder. But do we really need a dog-pile of acrimony creeping into everything that happens or everything that gets made?

No. All you can say to something that shrill and animated is, “Right on, man” like you would a teammate who just scored all the points or “diieee!” like you would to someone you intend to punch in the throat. As creative as the rants can get, (I’m looking at you, Lindy West) they constrain criticism to this bro-like tete-a-tete rather than a meaningful dialogue.

What’s worse, these harangues give everyone a sense of unearned permission to savage anything and everything at will -- watering down the very act of criticism itself and and de-clawing the potency of snark. Think I’m wrong? Go deep on Yelp or hop into the comments section of, well, anything on the internet. There’s a world full of ham-faced mouth-breathers digging at their local taco stand because they aren’t the French Laundry -- or tick-shaped hosers getting all uppity about a movie that ever so slightly fails to live up to their hilariously unrealistic expectations. There, only the loudest and most polemic of opinions get all the likes and dancing bears and thumbs up and the digital baubles.

To wit, I have no doubt that TotalHack97's next attempt to get laughs making a shitty Pixels joke will stretch the boundaries of his employer’s good taste. I can see him trying, “Pixels killed my dad” or something even hackier and even more cringe-worthy. Or he’ll do so to the next hate target du jour.

What’s even worser than that (yeah,whatever, things can be worser): will people like MovieBob prevent big studios from making something supposedly as bad as Pixels? Nope. The lesson that studios probably learned from his inartful savagery (if they even watched it) wasn’t to improve their game or to trust in creator’s tastes. They probably learned not to make video game movies ever again -- even ones that would come close to soothing the inner suckling-pigs of all those overwrought haters. Instead, they’ll go to the juked-up metrics and we’ll end up with so much more middle-of-the-road pap meant to appeal to everyone, thus satisfying no one.

At this point, hacky attempts at barbs and unrefined rants are making me a tad Rand-ian and I don’t want to be. I’m starting to feel like the “hustle as hard as you hate” crowd might have a point and I don’t want to be the guy that gives them credence. I don’t want to get all, “These are people who never had an imaginative bone in their bodies for life to trample. Only a Prime Mover can make great works of art” or whatever will go into Trump’s next stump speech. I don’t want to believe that criticism is only for professionals, but I want criticism to at least mimic professionalism. There’s plenty of bad time-wasting art out there, let’s serve it up proper with calculated restraint.

Besides, shouldn’t we be saving our shrillest and our barb-iest low-brow diatribes for the things that truly matter...like Fantastic Four? After all, I heard from my dear sweet mom (don’t worry, she’s been on the internet for a while now) that it was a,” rapey-as-all-fuck, retroactively-childhood-molesting, puppy-drowning, mess of befouled troglodyte taint-pustule suppurations that was slurped up and shat out by syphilitic Juggalos at The Gathering.”